In conversation with Nadiia Forkosh

In conversation with Nadiia Forkosh

In conversation with Nadiia Forkosh

1 year ago
I had the pleasure of chatting with Nadiia Forkosh, a Ukrainian artist who explores the intersection of traditional art and NFTs. Born and raised in Kiev, Nadiia’s life was turned upside-down after Russia’s invasion in February. Yet, even as a deep, wordless pain flashed through her eyes during our Zoom meeting, I was moved and humbled by her bravery, her positivity, and her faith in the healing power of art. Not only is she optimistic, but she has also proven to be selfless. Nadiia shares the proceeds from her NFT sales with fellow displaced Ukrainians, and plans to continue for as long as it’s needed.
RE: Thanks so much for making time to speak with me! I understand that you’ve had to leave your home in Kiev since the war began; where are you now, and are you safe?

NF: I’m in my friend’s home, so the internet connection is good here…no sirens now. I hope there won’t be any this hour, because life these days…sometimes we just stay in the basement, and you can’t do anything.

I’m on the border of Ukraine and Romania. It’s a safe place. I live and I was born in Kiev, but since February I couldn’t go back there, so I’ve been here.

RE: Have you been able to retrieve any of your canvases from Kiev?

NF: Sadly, no. I will not be able to return to my art studio…I lived on the 22nd floor in Kiev, and it’s really dangerous to be there right now.

RE: I’m so sorry that you had to leave your home and studio behind. How long have you been an artist?

NF: Since I was born I started to draw, so I’ve always been an artist. I’ve done some nameless work, I’ve worked in advertising and in traditional art, so I’ve done a lot of different projects over the years.

What I like is digital and traditional art together; I’m not going to split these. NFTs allowed me to be a digital artist. To me, that means that I create both physical painted canvases and unique NFT works, and I see it as a possibility for me to bring art to a new level.

It’s like music. We have traditional music, and then later we developed digital music. But when we unite them, we have something more unique, something special, and that’s what I do with visual art.

RE: So it sounds like you’re working to create a hybrid of the two styles.

NF: I’m here to engage the viewers, it’s how they participate and how they can take art in as an experience. I think about how visitors react in a gallery when they see a canvas versus how they react to digital art in a gallery.

I think in traditional, when you see a canvas, the viewer has to react to the canvas to understand it more. But when you see the digital form of art, there can be so much there: animation, music, sometimes you can touch and smell the exhibit…it’s easier to eat, is how I describe it!

What I’m investigating, these reactions: this is the way I move in art.

RE: I realize this is a sensitive subject, but have you found it difficult at all to create art and find inspiration during your displacement?

NF: For ideas [to make art], no. In my work, the most important thing is the human. I investigate the human, it’s what I’m interested in. So for me, there’s been no problem finding inspiration. It’s more an issue of time because I’m preparing documents, moving around, raising funds, helping others. You can’t avoid it now.

What I’m doing: I never ask people to hate other people…even if I don’t like what they’re doing, as is the case with this war. When people look at my art, I ask them to look at the humanity at the heart of a situation. It’s harder painting canvasses right now of course; it’s not possible to have paint delivered currently.

The most important thing right now is resuming the profession, finding work wherever I can. 

RE: It’s interesting that you say that, because I was struck by the amount of color and hope that I saw in the work you have posted on SuperRare. It seems as though your work has not shifted so much stylistically, would you say that’s true?

NF: I’ve had different experiences in my life. Hope and belief and positivity can create miracles. That’s my relative experience; I’m a positive person. And sometimes a situation is really hard and people say ‘this is too bad, I can’t possibly hold all this,’ but we have to. We have to live, we have to believe.

It’s the core of my energy, the well and source of what I’m doing. No matter what happens, I will be who I am, I’m fighting for it and yes, it’s really hard. It’s exhausting, really.

But no one promises that it will be easy.

RE: I’d like to talk a little about your work with NFTs now; I understand you were minting them before the war. When did you start minting your art as NFTs?

NF: Since 2020. I got an invitation and for me, it was a unique experience.

For me, the NFT is the possibility to create canvasses that exist in another dimension: a digital dimension in its original form. It was a blow-up for my digital art so I was ready to take it and go on, it’s a new step!

I think there was a step to the moon, and now here’s a step to the digital, for us artists. It’s just such a powerful form, I think you could argue that it’s the most powerful thing that has happened to the art world since the Renaissance.

I’ve been in an exhibition in London. They took twenty-one of my painted canvasses and twenty-one NFTs. So it was a canvas, and then a screen, canvas, screen, and people could interact with both forms of art at once. 

People were saying ‘wow!’ It’s so unusual to see digital that you could see and touch, and smell, it was something people didn’t expect. This is the way I want to move: to make more interesting things that viewers can interact with in more powerful ways. That’s what I’m doing with NFTs.

That was in London, it was February 2022 and as soon as I got back the war started.

I’d been organizing it for two years, to get the canvasses together, to put everything in the right place. It was a great event and then I was back to this—horrible situation.

RE: So how long does it take for you to create a piece of artwork that you’ll mint as an NFT?

NF: Usually I have albums, sketchbooks, and each day, I create an idea in sketches. But I’m not usually satisfied with them, for one project I might make ten sketches, all different forms. For me, to create a high-quality NFT, that usually takes three weeks. Three weeks until I’m satisfied with the quality that I have. I know some artists can create them in two or three days, much faster. But I’m not satisfied with the result and the clarity of the idea. I’m looking at clear form: an idea that can be absolutely understandable for viewers. 

Yet meanwhile they should have perfect composition, perfect shape, so I can’t make it in a few minutes. It might not be great for popularity because I don’t have a huge quantity, but I prefer to have an image that I’m really happy with when I upload it and when a collector buys it, I’m sure they can estimate what it’s worth.

RE: You’re clearly very inspired by the metaverse that NFTs have established for artists. How did you use proceeds from your sales to support fellow refugees in Ukraine?

NF: Firstly we organized a public fund. We sold several NFTs through Solana currency. We sent some of the money to a maternity hospital because there were newborn infants living in the basement there.

With my sales, I’ve been sharing the profits since then. You’re around so many homeless people that have nothing—I’m ten kilometers from Bucha. They have nothing there, just clothes, what they fled in.

So we provide them with bread, food, clothes. I always share when I make sales. These aren’t just strangers, they are families that you know, members from your community and their children. So I always share some part of my profits to people who need it.

I have a soul, so I have to share.

You understand that you could be in their place—they lived like you down the street, and now they need clothes. It’s not possible to avoid this in these times.

The problems in Ukraine, there’s a lot of corruption now, some groups have organized funds and collected money—and then they don’t share it with those who need it; they buy things for their own purposes. So I have found that it’s better to buy food and medicine directly so the money doesn’t ‘fly away.’

RE: How do you choose where to send the funds to? GoFundMe, or through PayPal, or do you just bring funds directly?

NF: All of those. For example, my friend called and said a family with three kids she knew, they were trying to travel somewhere more safe, they had no gas in the tank of their car, no food. So she asked me to bring them what I could; bring them food, give them some money for gas. Necessary, emergency things. If somebody needs you, you go!

RE: What an amazing unity you’re describing amongst the refugees and civilians from Kiev.

NF: Yes, you know someone who knows someone who knows someone who could use some help, so everyone comes together.

RE: Have you worked with other artists to raise funds?

NF: I’ve helped some Ukrainian artists, explaining what freelance is. Many people have lost their jobs and are now turning attention to their hobbies, so if they’ve always liked art, they want to try and create some to sell. So I’ve explained in free lectures, people can show up, or tune in online and I explain how to create NFTs, how to get signed up.

Everyone now has the Internet. Even if it’s hard, I really try to work with a schedule. I decided to just make a free lecture so people could access this information for those who have jobs and don’t. I explain the risks, scams online, I get it. I was hacked several times. I explain how to avoid it, how to be careful, how to create work that can be sold in the future.

RE: Tell me more about the challenge of ‘remaining human,’ as you described it.

NF: When it happened first, of course, I was in shock. Everyone was in shock. For a week, I was in shock, it was not possible to deal with, it sounded like a washing machine, it was a scary sound, hearing too many ‘booms.’

Then I realized, you have to work. It’s really helpful when you dive into the work, when  you communicate, for example, like the SuperRare community, a lot of them have been asking how I’ve been doing, they’ve organized a workspace. It’s really good to dive into.

Because the news around you, it’s absolutely horrible. You hear every day that people are dying, bombs are going off. In this case, the work has really helped me to stay alive. To be human. To concentrate. Even when you’re working with a digital template, you’re able to forget for just a little bit what’s going on around you. So thank god I’m fortunate enough to work, it’s been great.

RE: I’m sure that the person you were before February 24th and the person that you are now are two separate people. Do you sense any change in the art that you’re creating, or is that a constant for you?

NF: Of course it’s changing; it’s changing and the humanity in my work, I go on with it. I want people to understand each other through the visual. Nowadays, people dread what you’re going to say about the world, nobody has time to themselves, no one wants to concentrate, because there’s too much information, that’s normal today. But I think that people need to hear each other.

Try to understand, we’re in a different mentality. Just trying to understand what another person is going to say: that’s much more important. Biologically, when there are a lot of species in one place, we get angry, it’s normal.

But I believe that we’re not just creatures, we have something that can’t control us, something that we can call human. I’m going to emphasize in my work more and more that we are not just a crowd; we have a point of view and we have to listen to each other because that can prevent more war in the future. That’s my standpoint and I want to make brighter things in my work, make things bright like they were before the war. 

RE: What is next for you? Do you plan to continue working primarily in digital art and NFTs?

NF: Yes, I’ll go on my way with digital art. I want to continue to create NFTs to sell on SuperRare.

All my life, before NFTs, the galleries would plead with me. I worked with galleries that worked only with canvasses, and I’ve worked with galleries that only did digital forms. I want to show that nowadays, an artist can exist in a unique form and those styles shouldn’t be divided. We’re contemporary! If you’re a contemporary artist, you can be in both dimensions—in reality with canvasses and oil or acrylic, and also with animation and superimposed music that can exist as a core of this metaverse.

RE: Do you have any advice for other creators out there who are trying to break through into NFTs, or just to create new art in general?

NF: I don’t think I have anything new to say that artists haven’t heard before, but I’ll try to extract from my experience. Firstly, never give up. Learn, and learn the new.

These days, there are so many new computer programs. They have so many new opportunities to work with 3D sculptures, animation, try everything that you like! Try and complete something, don’t just try. Even if it’s hard, you fear you’ll have no time—see a project to the end. I really believe that creating is making you better.

Thirdly, read about, and go to exhibitions. When you see these works, you’re immersed and involved in it, you digest it a little, and that’s how a new idea is born. I’m not saying it’s copying what you’re seeing at exhibits, just that new ideas get you moving forward and creating better as an artist.

That’s my way, and this formula is working. 

20

Rebecca Endres

Rebecca Endres is a freelance writer and office administrator working in New York City. She currently lives on Long Island. She is the winner of the 2018 New School University MFA Chapbook Contest in Poetry. Her poetry has been published in Thin Air and The Best American Poetry Blog.

Art

Tech

Curators' Choice

Beyond the self: a conversation with Ines Alpha

Beyond the self: a conversation with Ines Alpha

Above: Ines Alpha x Diane Sagnier. Image courtesy of the artist.

Beyond the self: a conversation with Ines Alpha

2 years ago

New augmented reality filters are popping up daily, adding a playful note to the social media game. Still, it’s been tricky to determine which creators’ contributions pass through an artistic process and which do not. Indeed, some skeptics are unwilling to consider AR effects a full-fledged art practice, as we would for painting or other mediums accepted by the establishment as art. But norms are changing. In Ines Alpha’s words Augmented reality is just another tool artists can use. Art doesn’t have to be a painting or a sculpture. It evolves with time and with our society as well. Anything that can help an artist to tell a story, to share a different point of view, can be considered art. It’s not the tool that creates the art piece; it’s the artist’s intention. And that’s how you make the difference between a basic filter and an artistic one. Not the majority of AR creators have a specific and personal vision or message they want to share with the world. Most of them just enjoy experimenting with the software.

Based in Paris, Ines is an artist whose practice is steeped in internet culture. (She has been an enthusiastic Tamagotchi breeder since forever). While honing her career as an art director, she binge-watched 3D creatives’ online tutorials in her spare time. Her journey to becoming a full-time digital artist began when she teamed up with creative mainstays, such as the music producer Panteros666, to co-produce video clips featuring otherworldly blobs and ethereal shapes. In relatively short order, she was drawn to augmented reality. Using 3D makeup, she has cultivated a signature style that challenges received ideas of what fine art can be. Ines is building up the beauty industry’s future. Nothing less.

Ines Alpha by Nathan Beer

The artist’s home in Paris by Nathan Beer

HyperEmotionalSkin, in collaboration with Adrien Chuttarsing. Image courtesy of the artist.

Cracking the reality dilemma with AR filters

Nowadays, it’s  a cliché to hear creatives talk about blurring the lines between the real and the virtual. The catchphrase more often lends itself to boosterism than a substantive aesthetic statement. Ines’s work however, fully merits such an otherwise careworn description. Her work in 3D and AR deepen an optimistic narrative that fully embraces our hypermediated era.

When I started experimenting with 3D, it was pretty natural for me to suddenly add 3D elements on a face as makeup,” she explained.I used post-production software for my first projects, and AR seemed way too complex to learn at that time. But post-production means creating a tailor-made 3D design, so no one can try that 3D makeup look on once the video is done. I knew I would need to use AR at some point to democratize my work. Because how can I call my art ‘makeup’ if no one can wear it?” To make the magic happen, Ines gradually integrated AR into her creative process. Pointing to the medium’s world-building potential, she declared, “You can create things that would be almost impossible or at least a nightmare to reproduce in the physical world.” Apart from its constructive functionality, Ines has found AR to be the perfect medium to deconstruct the beauty and makeup standards.

Because how can I call my art ‘makeup’ if no one can wear it?

— Ines Alpha

ImpulsTanz x CinCin / Filter developed with HongweiTang. Image courtesy of the artist.

Ines Alpha by Nathan Beer

Ines Alpha by Nathan Beer

The artist’s home by Nathan Beer.

“I’ve always been into adding 3D elements in our physical world, using what we can see with our eyes and augmenting it with digital software to make it more magical,” she told me. “I love the effect it has on your brain, the questions that can arise while watching those kinds of work or even making them, tricking the brain into believing everything is real.” 

This mind-luring approach, specific to AR, is also closely aligned with the internet era’s identity fluidity, a core component of her explorations that has been evolving with the rise of social networks and the rate at which the web is shifting. Along these lines, Ines’s filters tackle self-awareness, meta-aesthetics, and beauty. Using the latest in tech to generate futuristic identities, she questions the underlying societal values of facial depictions. The iridescent layers of her creations are meant to empower people, giving them the freedom to play around, create, and embody a new screen-native self. Her hope? To entice people to embark on a mixed reality experience that, over time, may help them temper IRL frustrations and fears.

Ines has been lucky enough to keep her creativity and personality in most of her creations, some of which illustrate her universe with more intensity and trueness, such as projects developed using multiple mediums. Developed in collaboration with creative coder and AI enthusiast Adrien Chuttarsing, her HyperEmotionalSkin connects makeup with users’ feelings and generates designs that depend on the emotions users are willing to show the camera. Meanwhile, her alpha beauty booth–a collaboration with digital artist and engineer Sava–lets you apply your 3D makeup look with your finger. Easy-to-use and inclusive, these digital makeup wearables fill social feeds as they allow users to participate in the creation of art. It’s a smart way to increase the visibility of her creations as algorithms become more and more untamable each day. 

αƖρнα Ɓєαυту ƁσσтнImage courtesy of the artist.

From social apps to the crypto space

To a large segment of people, NFT art is synonymous with little more than over-hyped digital status symbols. For others, including me, this revolution has been a significant turning point in art history, digital ownership, community building, and aesthetics.

Ines has been looking for ways to monetize her work. At present, smart contracts offer the most viable means for her to do so. “For now, it’s the only way to sell digital artists’ work with a proper certificate and trace it. That’s great news to make digital art accessible to more people, protect it and value our work more traditionally,” she mentioned, adding that ownership of AR is a slippery slope. “It’s complicated, especially when collaborating with big companies such as Meta. I have no idea what the law is about this, shame on me, but uploading my art to their platform makes it their own?” Still, these apps are the best way to display and share her work, and she hasn’t yet found the right way to link her AR works to NFTs. In particular, the filter-related ones are more of a self-triggered experience than an artwork because of their ephemeral nature. But, she is quite optimistic about the future. “I guess it’s not gonna be a problem soon enough anyways,” she said, as the ever-evolving features of NFT platforms widen the possibilities offered to creators a little more every day.

This new creative economy has been a game-changer for Ines. Web3 has allowed her to broaden the scope of her e-makeup creations which valorize a form of beauty that is more diverse, quirky, and open to imperfection than what is traditionally considered worthy of celebration. “It’s a good thing that art pieces that were not made in a traditional way have value now. That value has been given by people and not by a very selective privileged group. What’s beautiful or not doesn’t belong and doesn’t have to be decided by a niche of people.” Ines’s views on creative freedom and autonomous decision-making are key components to the Web3 ecosystem and its community ethos, and that’s why we are all in here.

From the few experiences she has had so far, the crypto space has been very kind to Ines.I’ve always felt that people working in the digital space were supportive,” she explained. “Always up to sharing knowledge, resources, and tips. It’s thanks to Nicole Ruggiero that I made my first baby steps in the community.”  

The guardian by Nathan Beer

Ines’s first NFT with Nicole Ruggiero “Tears in the wind.” Image courtesy of the artist.

Ines Alpha by Nathan Beer

The artist’s home by Nathan Beer

When I asked Ines what’s next for her, she told me that in addition to creating new filters and partnering with other collaborators, she has started exploring new ways to merge realities.  One such project is with a company that wants to produce stuffed animals with her 3D designs. “I hope this project will happen! It’s so exciting for me to be able to have physical versions of my work. I’m already thinking of also having accessible (price-wise) and sustainable NFT versions for those who can’t afford the plush toys.” As for the rest, it will mostly depend on what chance may bring. Yet for the time being, Ines remains committed to exploring how makeup will be re-shaped through Web3 and the metaverse. How will this conceptual space affect our standpoint and, more globally, our identity? This may keep her busy and creative for a while.

20

Benoit Palop

Benoit is a French project coordinator, digital content strategist, writer, and curator based in Tokyo. He has been digging into web culture and digital art since the early aughts and sharpened his knowledge with an intensive academic journey, including a Master's degree in research in digital media at Sorbonne University in Paris. He has collaborated with companies, studios, and media such as MUTEK, VICE, i-D, Society for Arts and Technology, Club Media, and The Creators Project (VICE & Intel), to name a few. Through curatorial projects, research, and writing, he likes exploring issues such as networked culture, social media practices, and media archeology. He also enjoys talking about NFTs and ramen.

Art

Tech

Curators' Choice

Ruby 9100m and the art of breaking reality

Ruby 9100m and the art of breaking reality

Above: Ruby 9100m. Image courtesy of the artist.

Ruby 9100m and the art of breaking reality

2 years ago

Unless you’ve been logged off for a while, you’ve noticed that virtual beings have seeped into every corner of the internet. You may not like it; still, you have to accept that they’ve unlocked many new creative possibilities in fields from fashion to art to media. With ever-evolving storytelling, flexible designs, and unique online social experiences, they adjust to the wills of their audiences, followers, and creators. Invented by Hong Kong-born and raised artist Ruby (the IRL one), her avatar, Ruby 9100m, is one of these computer-generated entities, and has become well known through net culture and digital fashion communities over the last few years.

I first came across Ruby’s universe circa 2015. At this time, she was pretty active on Tumblr, sharing a daily dose of Internet gems and a e s t h e t i c visuals, kinky anime captures and slick fashion snaps you could scroll through for hours. She was also leading the Wee Girls Club, a global community of “multidimensional girls with a strong sense of culture, art, music, and design.” At that time, she was already ahead, showing a deep understanding of the web subculture’s ecosystem, aesthetics, philosophy, and community. It was around 2018 when she started embodying her digital self. The vanguard CG girl and transhuman she has been splitting her life with is her way of blurring the lines between what it means to be a physical and virtual being. “Ruby is my virtual extension and a vessel for myself to express my emotions and aesthetics freely. I also see her as my daughter,” she said while introducing her digital self.It’s like I built her, and I have to be very responsible and attentive for her as an identity. I take a meticulous approach to her branding and development. Also, she doesn’t have friends like other virtual beings, and I’m her best friend.”

Ruby 9100. Image courtesy of the artist.

Rendered identity as therapy

Some people may have a rough time catching up with the virtual-everything frenzy or may not be very into cyber-girl subculture. Others can still find the overall concept of digital personas a bit blazé and not artsy enough. However, net culture freaks will have a blast digging into the conceptual ideas that form Ruby 9100m’s narrative core: a well-crafted exploration of how the internet has been shaping new existences.

Ruby started away from reality as soon as she intensified her online presence as a fashion influencer while still a student, mainly using Tumblr. For her, understanding herself online is to understand herself in the real world–a metaphysical thought she has struggled with since an early age. “I had trouble valuing myself as a human being. It might be because I grew up in a traditional Asian family and a small city where I never felt I belonged. Plus a lot of unfortunate experiences in childhood that came along,” she confesses. “I was always trying to fit in, but I could not.”  

She started sporting head-turning looks and got internet-breaking attention. “I was always trying to be someone people would like to see!” she said, insisting that other people’s gazes likely kicked off her shift into becoming a transhuman. “I guess the process of being looked at on social media at the age when I was still finding myself gave me extreme anxiety,” she said. “I suddenly thought that as everything we see online is highly calculated and not true, maybe I could create my second identity to replace my existence there so I can separate my real life from online life.”

Unlike most teams that manage these 2.0 muses, the one-woman team Ruby (helped by her feline assistant Lulu the chub) does not hide the Daz Studio and Marvelous Designer software intervention to bring her CGI alter ego to the digital realm. Likewise, she does not hide her emotions. Across the screen spectrum, the genuineness she shares presents a personal vision of the merging point of the real and the virtual: a daily crossroads of realities that are no longer up for discussion in 2022.

This total transparency is one of the catching aspects of her practice. It considerably expands the scope of her work from an artistic and sociological point of view and reduces the gap with her audience. Indeed, contrary to other V-influencers who are nothing more than an amalgam of current trends, Ruby 9100m reflects her IRL creator in all aspects and pertinently questions the relationship we all have with our own virtual self. “I guess the uniqueness of Ruby is that she is not completely virtual,” Ruby answered when asked about the singularity of her creation. “Ruby 9100m might appear to be the most virtual among avatars, but she isn’t plotted to represent any social norms or issues,” she states. “I guess this also somehow makes her ethically neutral. And business wise, her authentic identity and existence are also unique instead of being an industry-made character only for making money.” She definitely keeps a minimum distance from the competition and always favors a critical and creative approach despite her involvement in commercial projects. It’s a slippery slope she’s managed quite well so far.

Ruby 9100m. Image courtesy of the artist.

From the closet to the metaverse

Fashion has always been a central piece of Ruby’s practice. Not only because it helped boost her self-confidence, but also because it is intrinsically related to the work she unfolds with her avatar. Her sharp sense of style and the eye-catching futuristic design of her 3D renders are her signatures, and they’ve captured attention. They brought her to collaborate with some of the industry’s mainstays like Nike, Adidas, Ambush, Bvlgari, Vivienne Westwood, and The Fabricant. In addition to increasing her profile and bringing her into the public sphere, these opportunities have provided an additional way to make her art visible.

Virtual fashion was a mandatory step as she fully embraced the virtual world with Ruby 9100m. Still, she had no educational background in fashion. “Everything I learned about fashion and art is from my experience, tryout, and passion. As a real-life fashion influencer, I liked to style myself when I was younger. And now I still style a lot but all that for Ruby.” Like many creators, she sat down during the pandemic and broadened her tool kit. She self-taught Marvelous Designer and learned how to build digital clothing. “I feel so amazing to be able to create anything I want to wear, but I cannot find it IRL. Digital fashion is a must in the industry. Other than minimizing the cost of production, it gives fashion even more possibilities for creativity.” 

Looking towards the future and how digital clothing may evolve, Ruby supposes it will really depend on the technology and its acceptance to make virtual fashion’s utilities more approachable. “Combining physical and virtual products is also important to be the first step to make people interested in collecting virtual fashion items too!” she added. 

In a more democratic, free-for-all space than the classic catwalks can provide, this year’s Decentraland fashion week allowed fashion NFTs collectors to grab physical versions of their assets. This metaverse-based event perfectly resonated with Ruby’s point of view and demonstrates how non-tangible clothes can accelerate and facilitate the ongoing transition and mass adoption.

Ruby 9100m. Image courtesy of the artist.

A mindful approach to Web3

Aside from being one of the most stylish gals of the Tumblr-era, Ruby has also been at the forefront of web-based art for a while, working through online spaces, challenging realities, and carefully tackling topics in IP. It was foreseeable that she’d be involved in Web3, taking her creations to the next step and monetizing them through smart contracts. “I think NFTs bring a revolution and evolution for digital art,” she said. “With encrypted technology and values added to digital art, it is no longer just ‘internet art’ that is hard to value but also now considered as one of the most important mediums in the art industry.” 

However, she has been very cautious regarding the tokens’ pros and cons, using blockchain with tweezers and keeping her drops only for significant moments. “I usually do collabs with other platforms, companies, and artists for NFTs instead of just minting my work. I believe the creative process and concept are more important than just putting it [out] there.”

Joining the crypto world also contributed to spotlighting her works. It allowed her to reach an ever-growing community, diversify her audience from a niche fan base to the mainstream, and provide a better understanding of her practice. “One interesting fact is that NFTs bring Ruby more male audiences, while before most of my audience and followers were women and genderless people,” she noted.

Although she has not been deeply involved in any Web3-powered metaverses yet, and still has a long way to go and so much to learn about this blooming ecosystem, she is eager to explore its creative potential and add some new layers to her work. “It would be amazing to create a virtual and open space for Ruby with the world she could live in, with everyone’s effort to participate. As I didn’t purposely set any physical space for her to be in, it would be inspiring to see that in the future.”

Next steps: Playing with AI and Algorithms

Regarding how she envisions the coming months (and years) for her other half, she is thirsty for new ways to express herself and push the boudaries of creation and storytelling, whether using tech tools or not. “My ultimate goal is to make her an AI prototype,“ She said before concluding. “It would be astonishing to see the algorithm while Ruby comes to life and to communicate with a person who is supposed to be me, but maybe not! Apart from this, I have been working on transitioning Ruby’s current appearances into fine art. Stay tuned!”

20

Benoit Palop

Benoit is a French project coordinator, digital content strategist, writer, and curator based in Tokyo. He has been digging into web culture and digital art since the early aughts and sharpened his knowledge with an intensive academic journey, including a Master's degree in research in digital media at Sorbonne University in Paris. He has collaborated with companies, studios, and media such as MUTEK, VICE, i-D, Society for Arts and Technology, Club Media, and The Creators Project (VICE & Intel), to name a few. Through curatorial projects, research, and writing, he likes exploring issues such as networked culture, social media practices, and media archeology. He also enjoys talking about NFTs and ramen.

Art

Tech

Curators' Choice

Does it pay to stay bullish on cryptoart in a bear market?

Does it pay to stay bullish on cryptoart in a bear market?

Above: from @ivonatau on Instagram

Does it pay to stay bullish on cryptoart in a bear market?

2 years ago

This article is part of a series

We’ve seen it all in the bear market: free mint metas, goblins taking reign, and an exodus of traders, collectors and flippers surrendering their NFT quests, perhaps to return for the next cycle… or perhaps not. What this has meant for the NFT market as a whole is a cataclysmic downturn of sales volume, and participants and observers of the market are in agreement that this is one of the worst crypto crashes to date. Whilst buyers turn out their pockets, asking ‘wen moon?’, one must also consider what the bear market means for artists. How do creators continue to build their careers in web3 whilst sales volumes plummet? What strategies can they employ to weather crypto’s winter? And come spring, will these efforts mean that cryptoart will finally prove a safer investment than PFPs?

How is the market faring as a whole?

In general, art as an asset class has proven to be a wise investment during recessions and economic downturns. During the 2009 crash, auction prices fell by 27.2%; but the art market made a healthy rebound just two years later. In comparison, the S&P 500 fell by 57% and it wasn’t until 2013 that the market began to restabilize. 1 Today, the general perception is that art makes for a robust alternative asset investment. To open the inquiry into how investments in digital art fare in a crypto bear market, however, is a slipperier affair, due in no small part to the inherently volatile nature of cryptocurrencies. Before concluding that crypto art makes for similar wise investments, it is therefore worth zooming out and comparing NFT art sales with the NFT market as a whole.

Punk9059, also known as NFTStatistics.eth, has been keeping track of market trends and sharing his daily findings on Twitter throughout 2022. On July 30th, he reported a steep decline in sales volumes and USD value on popular NFT trading platform OpenSea compared to the previous year, stating: “Last year on July 30, OpenSea volumes jumped from $10mn to $30mn and never looked back. Unfortunately, today will be the first time ever where NFT USD volumes are down year-on-year.”

This finding is in line with the analyses of NonFungible, the world’s largest NFT data resource, which revealed in their most recent quarterly report that the global NFT market is down 20% in sales volume. The total volume in terms of US dollars traded has experienced an even steeper decline, due to the lower values of cryptocurrencies such as Ethereum, and exhibits a 25% decrease from Quarter 1 of this year.2 Despite statistics being in the red, Nonfungible notes that the overall 25% decrease in the NFT market is relatively modest compared to overarching cryptocurrency trends. For example, the average price of an NFT has decreased by only 6%, whereas the value of cryptocurrencies has been divided by almost three during this period.3
What is most interesting to note from Nonfungible’s investigation is that the NFT art segment has been one of the least affected by the bear market when compared to categories like gaming.4 Compared to its close cousin–the collectible and PFP category–NFT art represents a much smaller segment of the market (with $430 million in USD volume traded in Q2, compared to almost $3.8 billion for collectibles), and yet it has experienced a much less sharp downturn. The quantitative data thus looks surprisingly reassuring for NFT art, but exploring how artists approach the bear market on a qualitative basis reveals the secret to how and why art fares better during trying economic conditions.

How do artists navigate bear markets?

By investing in artworks that collectors love, enjoy, and have a personal connection with, return on investment becomes a bonus, not the goal.
Given that the number of active wallets in the crypto space today has decreased by 33%, we can assume that amongst this figure is a slew of emerging artists who struggled to envision a career within the crypto space, and thus took flight from the bear.5 For those more fortunate and who have already built a reputation in the digital arena, sales have faltered, but new strategies are highlighting ways to beat the market.

Let’s take, for example, the 19-year-old artist FEWOCiOUS, who recently saw the sale of one of his older pieces, “The Sailor,” go for 350 ETH ($595,000) on the secondary market. “The Sailor” was minted in January 2021, and sold for 46 ETH ($80k at the time) to collector YeahYeah. Since, FEWOCiOUS has benefitted from numerous lucrative partnerships, such as a $2.16M sale at Christies and a partnership with RTFKT. Today, he remains one of crypto’s youngest and most successful artists, with traditional art market backing to boot. 

So how did “The Sailor,” an older work that in most contexts would be considered buried and forgotten, achieve the artist’s largest sale ever? The (not so) secret is in FEWOCiOUS’ dedicated collectorship. During this period, YeahYeah put “The Sailor” back on auction, and posted about it on Twitter repeatedly. The auction gained impressive traction, with even SuperRare’s CEO, John Crain, tweeting: “Art history is being written in real time.” The passion behind these posts attracted the attention of NFT patron extraordinaire punk6529, who subsequently placed the winning bid of 350 ETH for this sale. Here, it was the actions of two influential and loyal collectors that projected the artist into one of the most impressive sales the NFT market (let alone the bear market) has seen to date. In web3, artists have the unique opportunity to engage directly with their collectors and form genuine, lasting bonds. In the case of FEWOCiOUS, the dedication and care put into these relationships led to a sale that will undoubtedly result in plain sailing for the rest of the bear.

As for AI artist Ivona Tau, the bear market is the perfect time to focus on creating quality work and partnerships. Tau has previously sold works at Sotheby’s and Fauve auction houses, demonstrating an important and productive relationship with the traditional art market. Though incredibly successful in her practice, she has not seen the same gargantuan sales prices as artists such as FEWOCiOUS. Thus, Tau’s approach to the bear market is more down to earth, more tangible, and exposes a strategy that other emerging and established artists could adopt today. 

When asked if she had experienced a difference in the number of sales made during the bear market, Tau expressed, “I noticed that the secondary [market] is a lot slower. On primary there is not much difference, but only because I started minting way less frequently. In a way it’s good as it allows me to focus on the quality of the works, without the pressure to mint often.” During the slower sales period of the bear market, Tau also consecrates a bit more time to marketing her drops and establishing fruitful partnerships with galleries and auction houses. Developing the storytelling aspect behind her works, participating in Twitter Spaces, and organising giveaways for presale lists are some of the actions the artist has taken in the past few months. The result? A sold-out collection of her long-form generative art series in seconds, “as if it were not a bear market at all.” 

Indeed, despite fewer sales and a devaluation of Ethereum and Tezos, Tau remains positive about being an artist during the bear market: “There are many opportunities for artists who persevere, as many will quit the space during the down times. On one hand it helps to increase visibility through less noise in the space, but it also allows for easier connections with galleries, DAOs, and collectors. The important thing to remember is that regardless of markets and trends, the connections you make are there to stay and they will take you to web 4.0 or whatever comes next.” 

Despite the break-neck speed of the NFT space, Tau reminds fellow artists that creating excellent work and a steadfast collectorship takes time: “It is a patience game. This is something that traditional artists are used to, but perhaps forgot with the NFT hype.”

Conclusion

What FEWOCiOUS’ and Tao’s bear market strategies have in common is a commitment to investing in, and engaging with, their communities of collectors. The qualitative perspectives of these artists, coupled with the somewhat surprising findings in reports such as NonFungible’s, appear to be cautiously optimistic about the NFT art market compared to the onslaught of articles and tweets that have preached the death and doom of crypto this past bear cycle. Does this mean that art on the blockchain echoes the hardy trends of the traditional art market during recessions? Can we truly assume that investing in digital art makes for smarter investments? Though these discoveries may lead one to believe that investing in cryptoart is ‘safer,’ to make such grandiose and premature conclusions would be a hit of copium. One must not forget that NFTs are still extremely volatile, no matter what the currency or category. For traders and collectors who are here to stick out the bear and stay in the market for the long-term, however, diversifying their assets and backing talented digital artists would not be unwise. 

There is an aphorism in the art market that dealers and advisors swear by: ‘Invest in art that you love.’ This rings just as true for art NFTs. By investing in artworks that collectors love, enjoy, and have a personal connection with, return on investment becomes a bonus, not the goal. This genre of collectorship contributes to the creation of a robust and sustainable NFT art market, which in turn outlasts the bulls and the bears.

20

Vienna Kim

Vienna Kim is an art professional with a specialization in new media and technologies. After her Bachelor’s in Art History from the University of St Andrews, and her Master’s in Art Business from the Sotheby’s Institute of Art, London, Vienna has dedicated her career to the intersection of the traditional art market and technology. She has worked as a freelance writer for five years, exploring a range of topics such as how the blockchain can empower African artists, Susan Sontag’s ‘Notes on Camp’ and the Met Gala, and various exhibition reviews and artist spotlights. Now based in Paris, France, Vienna is the Artistic Manager at digital art and NFT company ARTPOINT. She likes talking about games and NFTs.

Art

Tech

Curators' Choice

Cryptoart as public art: SuperRare and Taglialatella collab for Yorkville Murals

Cryptoart as public art: SuperRare and Taglialatella collab for Yorkville Murals

Above: from Yorkville Murals on Instagram

Cryptoart as public art: SuperRare and Taglialatella collab for Yorkville Murals

2 years ago

This week in Toronto, new murals and mysterious shipping containers spring up as part of Yorkville Murals, an annual open air celebration of the city’s culture, taking place this year from August 20 through 28.

There, SuperRare has partnered with fest founder Taglialatella Galleries to present NFTs for the first time in event history, constructing an otherworldly portal accessible from street level. The “guerrilla style” show highlights eight artists, curated by Taglialatella and SuperRare: Joe Iurato, Logan Hicks, Zoe Osborne, Guy Bourdin, Untitled Army, Omar Z. Robles, Raylivez and The French Kiss Lab. They span NFT superstars, the gallery’s regular roster, and rising local artists.

Materially disparate but both equally disruptive, street art and NFTs make a surprisingly natural fit.

This partnership between Taglialatella and SuperRare follows previous collaborations like an NFT exhibition at the fine art gallery’s Chelsea, NYC location earlier this year called “Digital Pioneers,” featuring three artists from the gallery’s roster and several blue chip artists from SuperRare’s NFT platform. This is where Joe Iurato and Logan Hicks actually made their NFT debuts.

Yorkville Murals has celebrated culture through public art every year since Taglialatella Toronto leader Alan Ganev founded the fest in 2019. Curated with a contemporary fine art bent, this year’s lineup of nine outdoor artists includes Fidia Falaschetti’s shiny pop cultural cynicism and semi-abstract portraitist Florence Solis—building on the legacy of previous highlights like a floor mural by mega gallery darling Nina Chanel Abney and a 2020 appearance by international muralist Emmanuel Jarus.

The event doesn’t stop at visual art. When he spoke to me, Ganev cited partnerships as a driving force behind Yorkville Murals. STOCKX, the W Hotel, and Hennessey have also come on board to create their own experiences this year. Cafe Artois is providing music, food, and drinks for revelers strolling Yorkville Avenue, closed to traffic just for the event. They’re also staging cultural activations like sculptures and art installations.

Ganev relocated to Toronto to help build and oversee Tagliatalatella’s fourth location. He started the Yorkville Murals program about a year and a half after they opened. Once he got the business up and running, Ganev started seeing resources at his disposal—particularly festival partner Ink Entertainment, who already had experience planning events that pop off, powered by their various restaurant and hotel properties.

“Yorkville Murals is a way to work beyond the scope of the gallery program,” Ganev said. “Yorkville Murals allows the gallery to be in constant communication with new talent, collaborate with that talent, collaborate with brands, collaborate with the city.” Some galleries transacting on the level Taglialatella does just set up shop and clock their sales. Through Yorkville Murals, this branch of their operations talks with the city itself.

The more he learned about Toronto, the more Ganev fell for the place and felt inspired to get involved with it. Toronto is Canada’s largest city—and the fourth largest in North America, after Mexico City, New York, and Los Angeles.

“It’s a city that has been growing at such an incredible rate, but its culture is barely catching up,” Ganev said. “It’s a very fertile ground for opportunity.” Besides, Montreal and Vancouver each had their own internationally acclaimed mural fest. Toronto was overdue.

Yorkville felt like prime real estate. Since Ganev spends so much time there, he’s built relationships critical to an event requiring big resources like walls to paint and power for permits. What’s more, the fashionable neighborhood (Chanel and Balenciaga are on the same block as Taglialatella’s spot) holds a deeply bohemian past—think Bob Dylan, Neil Young, and Margaret Atwood smoking weed outside a cafe, talking art and ideas. Literally.

Now, maybe unsurprisingly, it’s one of the most affluent areas in all of Toronto.

While that’s great for the residents, businesses, and visitors, Ganev noted it’s not necessarily the greatest for cultural advancement. Bloated power gets complacent—isn’t that the appeal of the paradigm busting that Web3 and NFTs seek?

“A lot of these brands are just recycling designed campaigns that are created in New York, that are created in Paris—then, what you see in the neighborhood is that it lost its identity,” Ganev said of the fashion ads dominating Yorkville’s blocks. “There’s nothing that you’re bringing into the neighborhood, it’s just a repetition of something else that is happening somewhere else.”

While Yorkville Murals strategically empowers Taglialatella to partner with artists a bit above their weight class, they equally prioritize partnerships that elevate local artists. Pair that with the opportunities created when Yorkville Murals started bringing other companies into the fold.

“SuperRare is a great example of how you’re able to collaborate with a technology-oriented company, creating a very cool concept—like a shipping container—putting it on Yorkville Avenue, highlighting emerging talent,” Ganev said.

Ganev had no prior experience in Web3 when he started presenting NFTs through the gallery. He’s always been more interested in the tactility of painting and the art business. “I feel a high from seeing this container on the street, seeing the structure of the container, very industrial, very rough, with the doors open,” Ganev said of the Yorkville Murals project with SuperRare. “Then there’s screens inside playing amazing animations and beautiful art.”

“Capturing people’s attention these days is very hard, and to innovate is very hard,” Ganev said. “You have to care and try harder. For me, this container is caring.”

“SuperRare is going beyond their digital space to create this container, the gallery is going beyond its traditional program to create this container,” he mused. “Here we are in completely different contexts, collaborating and doing something that is very interesting.”

Ganev recounted how, upon moving to Toronto, he immediately also fell in love with nearby Detroit, jumping across the American border six times his first year there. “There’s a gallery called Library Street Collective,” he said. “They’ve done so many cool projects within that city, collaborating with Daniel Arsham and creating beautiful mural projects on alleyways or buildings or taking over abandoned buildings.”

“I went to that city, and I got so influenced by the work that they were doing,” Ganev continued.  “I’m sure they’re inspiring other galleries, other companies, other creators, other curators to think like this.”

Yorkville Murals and all its experiments—like this year’s shipping container NFT show—are simply a function of their desire to engage Toronto’s cultural community by doing something different: collecting big brands like Aston Martin and SuperRare alongside leading artists of our time and local artists studying at university. It’s a cross-circumstantial idea exchange harkening back to that bohemian Bob Dylan era—maybe better because it’s an evolution, rather than empty recreation. The high fashion advertisements have already co-opted yesteryear’s revolutions.

Doing things differently means doing away with art’s elitism. Gallery shows at SuperRare’s SoHo popup, for example, utilize blockchain’s unique provenance powers. Visitors can scan QR codes alongside each piece to access artwork details and even see the entire ownership history with sale dates and prices. They’re fascinating, like stats for your favorite sports team. They also lay bare the formerly secret machinations of deals made behind the scenes, reducing the intimidation power the art world wields.

And like street art introduces creativity into everyday life, NFTs can be viewed anywhere in the world—even multiple times at once—without compromising provenance. That means bringing out the vast majority of art in this world that’s traditionally languished in private and institutional storage.

Even though Toronto’s a world class city, the white walled gallery space can turn people off. I know thoroughly fashionable folk in NYC who have never been to a gallery opening because they’re a little scared.

“The reality is that there’s these stereotypes that just alienate people that, as you said, have the resources to participate in this market and be a part of it, but they just feel completely intimidated…,” he remarked. “It’s very important that if you do cross that door, you’re treated with respect and you’re treated warmly so you come back, you talk to your friends, and you start building community that way.”

The very nature of the shipping container NFT showcase even has potential to go nomadic, empowering other communities to start building their own relationships with art.

Doing things differently doesn’t mean doing away with the resources of the present. “I do think it’s important to involve galleries, because there’s a lot of ways of presenting art and understanding the market that technology peers are not aware of,” Ganev said. “Coming into this space in the spirit of collaboration is key, and creating experiences that are innovative, that are challenging intellectually, but also created as an environment that people feel good in.”

It’s all a matter of conversation—especially in Toronto right now, where Yorkville Murals runs through August 28.

20

Vittoria Benzine

Vittoria Benzine is a Brooklyn-based art writer, personal essayist, and self-employed public relations professional. Her work has been published in Hyperallergic, Brooklyn Magazine, Whitehot Magazine, and more.

Art

Tech

Curators' Choice